|

Email Feedback
Return to Medical Expeditions Homepage
Report of the British Mount Everest Medical Expedition 1994
Compiled by Simon Currin
Table of Contents
Post Script - March 1996
Since the Report was first published in 1995 there have been some notable
events involving members of our team and those of teams that accompanied us:
In May 1995 Alison Hargreaves succeeded in her ambition to become the first
woman to climb Everest without supplementary oxygen. She did so in excellent
style and return to Scotland to huge public acclaim. Two weeks later she
departed for K2 as part of her ambitious quest to climb the three highest
mountains in the world within a year. She reached the summit of K2 in August but
was killed during the descent when she was struck by a freak storm. One of her
companions, Jeff Lakes, died later that night at camp 2 after struggling down
the mountain in the midst of the storm. Jeff was well known to members of the
BMEME as he was a member of the Lhotse team during our ascent.
Members of the other two Lhotse expeditions that accompanied us have also
made news. Erhard Loretan climbed Kanchenjunga with Jean Troillet. This made
Loretan the third person to climb all 14 eight thousanders. Benoit Chamou (of
the Italian Lhotse team 1994) accompanied Loretan and Troillet on their summit
day but failed to reach the summit (that too would have been his 14th eight
thousander. Chamou died during the descent.
The third High Altitude and Mountain Medicine Course at Plas y Brenin was,
once again, a total success with two excellent non medical contributions. Scott
Parazynski came from Texas to talk about his experiences as a Space Shuttle
astronaut. George Lowe, a member of the 1951 Everest reconnaissance expedition
as well as the 1953 first ascent team, talked about his Himalayan experiences 45
years ago.
Andrew Pollard and David Murdoch have written a book on Mountain Medicine
which will be published in the summer: High Doctor, Radcliffe Press.
The first academic publications arising will soon be appearing in the medical
journals. Much of our work has also been published on the Internet (see home
page address above).
Sixteen months after the returning from Everest we are in the happy position of
having generated a profit -£15,000. The company will shortly be renamed
(becoming Medical Expeditions) and new directors will be appointed to continue
the spirit and the work of the BMEME into the 21st century.
Introduction
In many ways the British Mount Everest Medical Expedition 1994 was one of the
strangest expeditions ever to go into the field. In all there were seventy five
members drawn from all over the country with a few members coming from as far
afield as New Zealand and America. Of the seven strong climbing team none had
ventured above 7,500m before and nobody had had any experience of organising
expeditions on anything like this scale. Many of the members aspiring to climb
some of the lesser (6,000m) peaks had had very little mountaineering experience.
Despite the huge costs involved the Expedition had no major sponsors and most of
the mountaineering and research was to be financed by the members themselves. To
make matters worse the Expedition had a set of objectives that went well beyond
simply climbing Everest and a few of its neighbours. They proposed to perform 16
medical research projects, 2 environmental projects, conduct an educational
campaign and promote the work of a Nepal based charity.
Not surprisingly before we left there were a few critics but the overwhelming
enthusiasm of the members carried the project forward. It is, with hindsight,
remarkable that the Expedition ever made it to Nepal and amazing that it
achieved all of its objectives. As you will see in the ensuing pages the
Expedition was most successful and it owes this success to the commitment and
resourcefulness of all 75 members. Most importantly all personnel returned
intact without serious accident.
The Research Teams grew over the years in scope and in stature and all research
projects were completed despite the best endeavours of customs, yaks, extremes
of cold and even avalanches at Base Camp. This Report summarises our preliminary
findings but we anticipate that around 40 academic papers will be published in
due course.
Everest evokes many images. To some it is a symbol of achievement to others a
mountain of refuse and an object of derision. The popular press goes out of its
way to make the image even more confusing. A few months ago a well known tabloid
newspaper printed a double page spread with the bold headline, "300,000 people a
year climb Everest". The article touched briefly on the environmental problems
that this influx of climbers had had and made the bold statement that the, "Boffins
on the British Medical Everest Expedition are going to install a loo with a
view" .
Fortunately the facts are rather different. We neither installed a super-loo nor
anything like it and, furthermore, only two Westerners, one Japanese and five
Nepalese Sherpas reached the summit of Everest in the 1994 post monsoon season.
The impression that climbing Everest is simply a matter of putting one foot in
front of another up a well worn yak track bears no resemblance to the truth.
Certainly there are few technical problems on the South Col route but nobody
should underestimate the difficulty of even walking on the flat at altitudes of
over 7,000m. let alone the cold and sense of isolation. Mix with that the
dangers of the Icefall, avalanche and altitude sickness and you have an
incomparable mountaineering adventure in a place filled with history. All of
those who ventured into the Western Cwm felt immensely privileged to be there.
We have been criticised for taking too many people into the Everest area but I
believe that we did this responsibly. The 75 strong team was divided up into 8
groups each with very different itineraries. At no point did the entire
Expedition assemble in its entirety and, most of the time, the members were
spread thinly throughout the vastness of the Khumbu region at a time of the year
when there were very few other trekkers in the area. All but 2 members did visit
Base Camp but the arrivals of the groups were staggered over several weeks so as
to minimise the numbers assembled there at any one time. Our environmental team
made an assessment of the real pollution issues that afflict Nepal and
demonstrated a very practical method for the safe disposal of human waste in a
fragile mountain environment.
Far from being a refuse tip Everest was in near pristine condition thanks to the
efforts of many clean-up expeditions and the reduced traffic in recent years. I
am glad so say that we left the mountain in the condition that we found it.
I hope that by drawing contributions from across the Expedition that this Report
will be more than a compendium of statistics and will evoke fond memories for
those who took part. The Expedition was remarkable in that all 75 members were
bonded by a strong sense of common purpose. It is impossible to describe the
exhilaration of being involved with such a happy and successful project but I
hope that this Report will go some way to convey the remarkable team spirit
enjoyed by so many.
The Report paints a broad picture of those who took part , their projects and
their exploits. Inevitably there are also a lot of dry fact and figures that may
be of use to future planners as well as reports on borrowed, donated or
discounted equipment.
Table of Contents
The Evolution of the Expedition
In spring 1990, somewhere between Lukla and Jiri after our first trip to the
Khumbu, Roddy Kirkwood and I realised that an Everest expedition was within the
reach of ordinary mortals. We had spent the previous month climbing on trekking
peaks and had shared much of the walk in with our New Zealand friends Rob Hall
and Gary Ball who were in the process of making their first successful ascent.
We had glimpsed the heart of an Everest expedition and our appetites were
wetted.
A few months later, during a wet weekend in Wales, I got talking with Andy
Pollard, who it seems, had been thinking about climbing Everest for years.
Before I knew it Andy had, with typical efficiency, written a host of letters to
trekking agents and signed them in my name. Within days the replies came rolling
in. Most of them said that there was no chance of climbing Everest this century
but one talked of a cancellation in 1994. We followed it up and by December 1990
we had an option on a permit. All we needed to do was find the Royalty (or peak
fee) in full ( then £2,400 ).
By March 1991 we had found a few people willing to speculate with their hard
earned cash and we sent the money off to Nepal - we were committed. In the early
days we were wonderfully naive about the fund raising process and assumed that
corporate sponsors would be falling over themselves to sponsor a bunch of
doctors climbing the highest mountain in the world. We were very relaxed about
getting the funds because our budget at this time was based on a peak fee
(Royalty) of £2,400.
Within weeks of getting permission we were delighted to receive the patronage of
Mr Chris Bonington and Dr Charles Clarke whose presence on the headed note-paper
gave the Expedition some early credibility. Lord Hunt became our third patron in
1992. The pre-eminence of our patrons undoubtedly made a significant
contribution to the prestige and eventual success of the Expedition.
Our first crisis came in December 1991 when the Royalty was raised to $10,000 by
the Nepalese Government and made to apply retrospectively. By now we had
recruited the nucleus of the climbing team. Charlie, Roddy, Andrew, Aidan and I
met in Stirling to decide whether to continue. It was the first time that we had
really got together and talked about our plans in any detail. It emerged that
none of us had any real idea how to raise the cash but that we were all
extremely enthusiastic and committed to the project. We decided to advertise for
paying members of the climbing team and await the result. By then we had
reasonably firm ideas about the research that we planned to do and we began to
form a fledgling research team.
We placed the briefest of advertisements in the climbing press and for weeks my
phone never stopped ringing. I was receiving about 5 phone calls a day from all
over the world and was staggered by the overwhelming enthusiasm and support that
people exuded over the phone. At the same time a few articles appeared in the
medical and Scottish Press and they too generated a flurry of enquiries and even
donations. We decided to organise an open meeting in the Lake District to gauge
the support first hand.
In March 1992 over 30 complete strangers gathered at Dunmail Raise for the
weekend and it became obvious that the mixture of medicine and mountaineering in
the Everest region was a very powerful attraction. We had a great weekend of
parapenting followed by a meal at the Old Dungeon Gill Hotel and the idea of a
Support Group acting as guinea pigs for the research was born. With so many
people now on board there was now no possibility of turning back.
In May 1992 the climbing team met in Oban and talked about attracting corporate
sponsorship. There was lots of talk about "sexy packaging" and hype but nobody
really came up with any good ideas.
The next bombshell erupted a few days before our next meeting at Blea Tarn in
July. The Royalty rose from $10,000 per Expedition to $10,000 per person.
Despite the horrendous weather and the gloom and pessimism preceding the weekend
I emerged from it convinced that the Expedition would go ahead. If the level of
enthusiasm amongst the Support Group had been high before it was now in the
stratosphere. Jim Milledge attended the meeting and agreed to be our Research
Advisor. He inspired us all with his excellent talk on the A.M.R.I. trip in the
Old Dungeon Gill Hotel. Ronnie Robb was asked to join the climbing team and
Alison Hargreaves also applied.
After that meeting Hannah Sutter kindly agreed to act as our legal advisor and
drafted a Support Group contract, formed us into a limited company and
registered us as a charity. What would we have done without Hannah? We prepared
a colour brochure which Ronnie miraculously got printed and wrote a handbook
which defined exactly what the Support Group would get for their money. By
September we were ready to start taking £200 pound deposits which were designed
to translate enthusiasm into commitment. I cleared off to South Africa leaving
my Mum to field the deposits as they flooded in. Within a few weeks we had
received 40 deposits with 2 years to go before the Expedition was due to leave.
An October meeting and public lecture in Hyssington turned out to be a major
turning point for the Expedition. In the audience was a relative of a trekking
agent in Nepal who later made the trip to the UK to capture our business. Thus
begun our relationship with Thamserku. A relationship which saved us in the
region of $30,000 and meant that with a large Support Group the Expedition could
be largely self financing - but this is all still for the future.
While I was overseas Andy Pollard ran the Expedition. In February 1993 Mark
Hoyle organised a press launch at the Aonach Mor ski fields. Brian Blessed
agreed to come and give a lecture which turned out to be one of the best
anecdotes of the Expedition - if you haven't heard it ask Ronnie (unfortunately
it's too libellous to put in print). Swanlind (who for a time acted as our PR
company) came along and made a promotional video and we had a good deal of
television and press coverage.
We had initially conceived the idea of running a medical course as a way of
increasing our prestige but it seems that once again we had underestimated the
market. All of the courses at Plas y Brenin were hugely successful in terms of
content, enjoyment, prestige and profit. The first one was in April 1993.
By the time of our meeting in the Lake District in July '93 the team spirit had
really begun to work. Groups were emerging and people within the Support Group
were beginning to plan and organise their own meetings. The Oldham Mountain
Rescue Team proposed a team building weekend at Saddleworth which they organised
and was a superb success.
In the autumn of '93 we made our flight reservations which represented another
quantum leap in commitment but I was getting hassled by our Nepalese agent to
hand over vast sums of money which we didn't have.
In November '93 Ang Tshiring Sherpa made the trip from Nepal to mid Wales to
seek our business. We took a huge gamble and ditched our existing agent in
favour of Thamserku and I believe this was the single most crucial decision of
the Expedition. With the savings that we made by using Thamserku we were able to
finance the Expedition without the need for a corporate sponsor. Thamserku, I
consider, provided us with an exemplary service. Inevitably we had some
difficulties and frustrations with the agent but they did cope admirably with
the enormously complicated logistics of our Expedition.
By now the Team was meeting at monthly intervals and each meeting would
typically be attended by 30 or 40 people some of them travelling from as far
afield as Devon and Aberdeen. A winter skills training weekend, once again at
Aonach Mor, was very successful and people who joined the Support Group as
"trekkers only" began to aspire to the 6,000m summits of Himalayan Peaks. I am
delighted to say that many ex hill-walkers now have a Himalayan tick to their
names largely due to the success of this weekend on a wind swept Ben.
In March we took our training overseas for the first time and a small group had
a go at ski touring in the Alps. This trip cost almost as much as climbing
Everest!
The crux came in May 1994. The Expedition's cash flow was largely dependent on
the Support Group following through and paying up on time. With increasingly
urgent demands for huge sums money from the Nepalese Government and already
committed to spending large amounts of other people's money, I confess that I
felt more than a little pressurised. Fortunately virtually all of the Support
Group paid up within a month of being asked, and we had a further surge of
recruits after a Plas y Brenin Course in April. In June we even received our
first corporate sponsorship - a cheque for £8,000 from the Royal Scottish
Assurance.
By June I was becoming increasingly confident and even beginning to relax. This
was helped by the rise in the value of the pound against the dollar. When I left
for Pakistan in July I knew, for the first time, that we had enough money in the
bank to cover most of our costs. It was, however, vital to maintain a tight
control on spending as our budget was only designed to break even and any
unanticipated expenses could have caused us a lot of problems. During the period
from incorporation to February 1995 we turned over £294,395.36.
Table of Contents
From the day of our first open meeting in March 1992 the Expedition acquired
an unstoppable momentum and although many hurdles were placed in our way we
never really doubted that the Expedition would take place.
By far the greatest problem to confront us was cash and the rapidly escalating
costs. Between 1992 and 1994 the Royalty alone rose from £2,400 to a staggering
£53,000. In addition our Support Group budget was first calculated when £1 was
worth US$ 1.87. When we bought our dollars in July '94 £1 was worth just US$ 1.5
and we had to buy 200,000 of them!
We were also unfortunate in the timing of our Expedition fund-raising. The 3
year campaign coincided with one of the deepest recessions ever and companies
had little cash to spare for public relations projects.
The quest for cash took us down some unlikely avenues. In the early days we were
persuaded that gloss and films were the answer and we were actively courted by
PR companies. It soon turned out, however that their naiveté was at least as
great as ours and we gained little tangible advantage. Right up until the last
minute various broadcasters and film producers were vacillating but in the end
we had to rely on my trusty video!
The meagre amount of corporate backing we did receive (5% of turnover) came
almost exclusively from the personal contacts of members and the huge quantity
of trawling mail-shots that we sent out were, in retrospect, a complete waste of
time.
In March '93 we all got very excited when we made a presentation to the board of
a major pharmaceutical company which was received with great enthusiasm. For a
while it seemed that our financial worries were over and the Expedition would be
completely underwritten. Alas it was not to be. Ironically the Everest 40th
anniversary publicity dealt us a cruel blow. Suddenly the press was full of
stories of refuse on Everest and bodies on the South Col and our backers pulled
out overnight.
The Expedition was fortunate in attracting the support of several distinguished
figures as well as our patrons. All who went to the Lloyd's climb will have fond
memories of the late John Smith who took time out of his busy schedule to browse
our research displays. Similarly Brian Blessed's lecture at Aonach Mor in
February '92 proved to be more than memorable!
We did achieve a reasonable media profile and the attention seeking escapades
that we organised proved to be most enjoyable. Few people, after all, get the
chance to swing from scaffolding in front of a swarm of cameras on the roof of
London.
Table of Contents
We spent a great deal of time over the 2 years before departure building the
Expedition into a cohesive team. At the same time we were keen to cultivate a
media profile compatible with a serious research expedition in order to ease our
fund raising problems. The events that we organised during the lead in period
were therefore designed to achieve both goals.
Managing the Team
The thought of taking a 75 strong Expedition of mixed experience and ability
to the high Himalayas is a daunting one. Coupled with that we wanted to conduct
a complicated research programme on as many members as possible and, of course,
climb Everest. The massive logistical problems threatened to limit the size and
scope of the Expedition and these problems exercised our minds quite
considerably about 18 months before our departure.
Fortunately we hit upon a very simple solution that worked very well. One year
before our departure we divided the entire Expedition into groups and encouraged
each group to meet and 'bond' before the Expedition as much as possible. By this
stage in the Expedition the team had been meeting fairly regularly for about a
year and some grouping was already beginning to take place, so it was a
relatively easy task to form the groups provided that there was scope for
individuals to move to another group if they preferred. In the end there was
hardly any movement between groups during the 1 year lead in.
Having formed the groups we then decided on separate departure dates so as to
minimise the pressure on the environment and on the hard pressed Research Team
at Base Camp. We were keen to avoid individuals within groups being labelled as
leader as this would carry with it unfair responsibilities and even possible
litigation. Instead we asked for volunteer spokespersons to act as the key
contact person and to co-ordinate pre-expedition planning and meets. In addition
we appointed one medical spokesperson to liaise with the Research Team and to be
responsible for the day to day data collection. There were so many doctors
around there was no need to name a group doctor.
On the whole the above structure worked well. There was a great deal of
variation between the degree of 'bonding' before the trip and most of the groups
remained intact and functioned well in the field. Some of the less experienced
group organised pre expedition instruction weekends in the UK.
The logistical key to the whole Expedition was to make each group as autonomous
as possible and to encourage them to plan their own routes and take their own
mountaineering decisions. This meant that each group would be totally self
contained with its own Sherpa crew and free to roam the Khumbu as it wished. We
did ask each group to present itself at Base Camp on arrival and before
departure from the Khumbu but imposed no other restraints. This independence
within the Expedition framework made, I believe, all the difference between ours
and a commercial trek. Members could plan their own objectives, train for a year
to achieve them and carry responsibility for their own decisions. The absence of
a guide, I am sure, heightened people's sense of satisfaction when they did
achieve their goals - and most of them did.
As far as I am aware there were very few problems within groups related to
decision making and everyone acted responsibly in assessing the conditions and
their own abilities. This is reflected by the fact that there were no accidents.
Groups seemed to be well satisfied with their sherpa crews and the quality of
cuisine.
Table of Contents
Medical Research
Logistics
In addition to the projects administered from Base Camp we planned to collect
a wealth of background data twice a day from Kathmandu onwards. This data
collection was the responsibility of the medical spokesperson and, in most
cases, this was performed meticulously. It is interesting that one of the non
medics turned out to be the most assiduous data collector and medical
spokesperson. Each individual was issued with a personal waterproof medical data
book and the information on this was regularly transferred onto hand held
computers. This data was eventually transferred to PC for processing. The palm
held computers made by Psion proved to be very versatile and reliable..
One of the greatest problems confronting the Research Team was to 'process'
groups quickly and efficiently as they arrived at Base Camp without confounding
other projects. Some projects took a lot longer than others, some involved the
administration of oxygen and some projects were dependent on having subjects not
exposed to oxygen. Before leaving the UK each member of the Expedition attended
one of two data collecting weekends which proved a useful dress rehearsal in the
relative comfort of laboratories in London and Stirling. Obviously these
weekends provided vital pre-acclimatisation data.
Inevitably groups were subjected to delays at Base Camp whilst they queued to
be poked and prodded but there were few complaints and the Research Team
collected a great deal of data.
Table of Contents
Aims
To make a safe and successful ascent of Everest and some of its neighbours.
To raise the profile of altitude related illness.
To make mountains safer for all by researching the mechanisms of altitude
related illness.
To seek, by research, sustainable ways of using remote and fragile mountain
environments.
To liaise with and involve local agencies in all environmental projects.
To make the first female ascent of Everest without supplementary oxygen and make
the first British ascent of Lhotse. .
To collect medical data from the summit of Everest..
To minimise environmental impact by using imported fuels and new technologies to
dispose of waste
To publicise and promote the work of the United Mission to Nepal (Nepal's
largest development organisation).
To promote informed discussion of the environmental issues associated with
trekking and mountaineering in the Himalayas and to facilitate the exchange of
scientific data.
Table of Contents
Achievements:
Dr Charlie Hornsby and Dr Roddy Kirkwood became the 21st and 22nd Britons to
reach the summit of Everest (8,848m) on October 11th 1994. They were accompanied
by Sherpas Dorje and Dawa Temba. During the season there were 3 other
Expeditions attempting to climb from the South (Nepal) and 7 from the North
(Tibet). Due to premature arrival of the Jet Stream winds only 2 Expeditions
were successful. In the whole season only 2 western mountaineers (Roddy and
Charlie), 1 Japanese (Muneo Nukita) and 5 Nepalese Sherpas succeeded. All
ascents were made using supplementary oxygen.
All fifteen of our medical research projects were successfully completed. In all
100,000 points of data were collected over the 3 month period from all 75
members of the Expedition. Much of the data is unique and, when processed,
should yield valuable information. Scores of academic publications are
anticipated in due course.
Some data was even collected from just 200 metres below the summit (8,600m).
Expedition members Chris Comerie, Mark Bryan and Paul Cleary reached the summit
of the neighbouring peak Pumori (7,140m).
Alison Hargreaves reached around 8,400m without supplementary oxygen before
being forced to turn back due to high winds and the risk of cold injury.
Members of the Expedition reached the summit of Island Peak (6,189m) and there
were many ascents of Lobuje East (6,119m), Parchamo (6,273m) and Pokalde
(5,806m). Only 2 out of 75 members failed to reach Base Camp (5,340m) which is
an unusually low attrition rate.
Our environmental team conducted a microbiological survey of water quality in
the Khumbu valley. They demonstrated a safe and efficient method for the
disposal of human waste at altitude which involved freeze drying followed by
incineration. All of the Expedition's waste was dealt with in this manner. They
also documented some of the environmental problems in Kathmandu and lectured to
the Royal Nepalese Institute of Science and Technology on aspects of waste
disposal. The Expedition abided by the environmental code of conduct laid down
by the UIAA and received a full rebate on its rubbish bond. Only 8 members of
our Expedition were allowed to climb into the Western Cwm. Overcrowding was not
a problem as only 21 climbers were attempting the mountain from the South side
this season. Base Camp was found to be free from rubbish on our arrival and we
left it in the same condition.
The Expedition has been extremely successful in its educational role. Four
residential altitude medicine courses have already taken place and another is
planned for late 1995. These have been attended by some 300 doctors and 250
laymen. One member of the Expedition is currently preparing a book aimed at GP's
covering all aspects of high altitude medicine. Many articles have also been
published in the medical press. As already mentioned we anticipate producing
scores of academic publications in 1995.
The Expedition formed a promotional partnership with the United Mission to
Nepal. The publicity surrounding the Expedition has been used by one of UMN's
funding organisations to highlight some of the problems afflicting Nepal. This
will form part of an ongoing fund-raising campaign. The Expedition has received
significant T.V. and press coverage over the last 2 years.
During the 3,000 man days the Expedition was in the field there was inevitably
some illness. Some of this was serious but there were no accidents and all
members returned safely and unscathed.
Table of Contents
Research Leader: Dr David Collier MBBS PhD, Research Advisor: Dr James
Milledge MD FRCP
Members of the Medical Research team include: Dr Peter Barry DCH MRCPI, Dr
Rachel Pollard FFARCS, Dr Andrew Pollard BSc MRCP, Dr Scott Frazer FFRACS and Dr
Nick Mason FFRACS, Mr Peter Pollard MSc, Miss Isla Martin, Dr Martin Rosenberg
PhD, Dr. Catherine Collier BSc MB BS, Miss Diana Depla FCOpth, Prof. G. Arden
FRCS, Dr Frederick Fitzke PhD, Mrs Angela Fry RGN, Miss Karol Howard RGN RCM, Dr
Gerald Dubowitz MB BS, Dr Simon Travis MRCP, Dr John Nathan MB BS, Dr David Webb
MD FRCP MFPM, Dr Chris Wolff MD MRCP, Dr Annabel Nickol BSc MBBS, Dr David Band
PhD, Dr O'Callahan MB ChB, Dr Datta MB BS, Dr Mike Mullen, Doncaster Royal
Infirmary.
Medical Institutions involved with BMEME;
St. Bartholomew's Hospital, Department of Clinical Pharmacology. St.
Bartholomew's Hospital, Department of Cardiology. Kings College Hospital,
Department of Physiology. St. Thomas' Hospital, Department of Medicine. Queen
Mary and Westfield College London, Department of Physiology. Charing Cross and
Westminster Medical College, Department of Medicine. Moorfield's Eye Hospital,
London. The Institute of Opthalmology, London. Veterans Administration, Seattle,
University of Washington, Department of Respiratory Medicine. Institute of
Medical Research, Northwick Park Hospital, Harrow. Stirling Royal Infirmary,
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. Birmingham Children's Hospital,
Department of Medicine. Edinburgh University, Medical Research Council Unit.
John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, Department of Medicine. Glasgow Western Royal
Infirmary, Department of Respiratory Medicine. Royal Hallamshire Hospital,
Sheffield, Department of Anaesthetics
Members of the Expedition who travelled to Nepal include: - A team of seven
climbers who attempted the ascent of Mount Everest. Five environmental
researchers who undertook projects to reduce the environmental and health
impacts of high altitude trekking, looking specifically at methods of dealing
with human excrement and the appropriate treatment of solid waste. Twelve
medical researchers who undertook fifteen projects into subjects as diverse as
the control of breathing during acclimatisation, balance and orientation,
carbohydrate absorption and the role of endothelin in high altitude pulmonary
oedema. Fifty members of the support group who climbed 6,000m peaks in the
Everest region. They acted as subjects in the research projects, and also
collected basic physiological data during the expedition.
Expedition members were allotted to one of a number of trekking groups,
designed to travel independently in the Everest region. Each group flew out from
Kathmandu to Luklha (2,800m), and then trekked to base camp (5,300m) over a two
week period or so. The groups were staggered so as to minimise their
environmental impact and so as not to overwhelm the researchers waiting for them
at base camp.
There were fifteen main medical research projects undertaken at base camp.
Each trekking group had a three day period (or thereabouts) at Base Camp to get
all their research done before they moved off and the next group arrived. As can
be imagined, it was sometimes difficult to get all the research finished in the
allotted time.
Apart from two groups, expedition members were meant to visit base camp on
two occasions, once within the first two weeks of their journey, before they had
acclimatised, and once ten days or more later, after acclimatisation. For two
groups, the second visit was not compatible with their climbing itineraries.
Conditions on the mountain: The first wave of expedition members travelled to
Nepal at the end of July, 1994. The monsoon is normally followed by a short
period of relative calm, with low winds and clear skies, before the jet stream
settles on the mountains and winter sets in. Unfortunately this year there was
no such period, and high winds, estimated at up to one hundred and twenty miles
an hour, swept the mountain almost constantly.
Despite this, members of the expedition were successful in their aims. The
Everest climbers all reached over eight thousand meters, with two successfully
reaching the summit at 8,848 meters, two of only three Western climbers to reach
the peak this season. The last of our climbers only turned back when high winds
blew away his tent and equipment from the South Col.
Three members of the Expedition climbed Pumori, an exacting mountain of over
seven thousand meters on the Tibetan border. Others climbed Pokalde, Imja Tse,
Parchamo and Lobuje mountains, all six thousand plus metre peaks.
One of our climbers suffered an acute stroke, losing the power in one side of
his body, and a member of another team lost the vision in one eye within a few
hundred meters of the summit. Both were accompanied down to our base camp to be
examined, and thankfully both have completely recovered.
The Research Environment: The original plan was to site Base Camp at Gorak
Shep and use the traditional site as an advance Base Camp. Although this would
have provided a much more comfortable environment in which to conduct the
research it would have made the climbing logistics vastly more difficult.
Base Camp was therefore sited at 5,330 metres on the rock covered glacier at
the foot of the Khumbu Icefall. Being the first expedition to arrive we sited it
as near to the foot of the Icefall as possible which is the prime location.
This, however, proved to be a mixed blessing.
Many of the Research team spent seven weeks at Base Camp which, in itself, is
a substantial feat of endurance. The altitude, cold, relatively poor food and
discomfort of camping on a creaking rock-covered glacier add up to create a
harsh environment in which to perform research. I have listed below some of the
other factors that made data collection difficult at Base Camp.
The first problem to afflict the Research Team was the absence of a suitable
tent. Thamserku Trekking (our agent) had agreed to supply a second large Ferrino
mess tent but unfortunately this never materialised. Instead we had to make do
with a variety of flimsy, single skin nylon ridge tents which sadly were not
weather proof. Excavating adequate flat sites for these tents proved a strenuous
and exhausting task. During the last weeks of the monsoon there were frequent
snowfalls and occasional rain showers and the tents had to be reinforced with
hired plastic sheets. During this period the typical weather pattern was a
bright, sunny morning with clouds and precipitation arriving by mid day .
Typically the afternoons were cool and were followed by a clear, cold night. As
the Expedition progressed the afternoons became less cloudy with less
precipitation.
Diurnal temperature variations (-18 to +25 degrees C) meant that use of some of
the equipment could only be used once the temperature had stabilised thus
limiting the length of the working day. Despite taking 2 new top of the range 8
horse power generators with us we had difficulty in maintaining a reliable power
supply. Much time was used in maintaining the generators. Furthermore research
time was also restricted to some extent due to electronic interference with the
radio schedules. More careful selection of a radio frequency would have avoided
this problem.
Some equipment did not survive the rigours of the approach march. Portable
computers fared worse two of which suffered screen failure and one hard drive
failure. Some work was delayed by the late arrival of equipment due to
freighting and customs delays followed by shortages of yaks.
The most devastating single event to afflict the Research Team happened in the
middle of the night. A large serac broke off from high on the Lo La (the 6,000
metre Col above Base Camp). The falling serac triggered an avalanche which
pushed before it a blast of wind. Although the avalanche itself did not reach
Base Camp the wind blast did. Such winds can be over 100 miles per hour and in
our case the blast was channelled several hundred metres horizontally before
striking Base Camp. The blast ripped selectively through the camp taking out 3
of the research tents but leaving many of the other tents untouched. The McInnes
Box tent weighing 78 kg was ripped up, blown clean over another tent and
travelled about 40 metres before colliding with the Mess tent. Ironically this
same tent had survived an avalanche at Camp 2 twenty years earlier on
Bonington's South West Face Expedition. Fortunately nobody was hurt but the
research tent and their contents were severely damaged. In the middle of the
night the Base Camp residents worked frantically to retrieve scattered gear and
rebuild the shelters. Despite the devastation much of the damaged equipment was
repaired and, with some improvisation, none of the projects were compromised.
Many of the Support Group subjects arriving at Base Camp were inevitably
suffering from acute mountain sickness and their fortitude in the face of a
battery of intensive medical testing meant that little data was lost due to
illness. However, the difficulty of crossing the glacier from Gorak Shep and the
cul de sac position meant that some data was lost. Understandably those groups
on a tight schedule were unable to make the return trip for the second data
collection session at Base Camp. Despite these many difficulties and the
shoe-string budget that they had to operate within the Research team collected
nearly all the data they had set out to collect. This is a tribute to their
dedication, improvisation and stoicism.
Table of Contents
Everest
Climbing Report
Team members: Simon Currin (Leader), Andrew Pollard (Deputy Leader), John
Sanders, Charlie Hornsby (summiteer), Roddy Kirkwood (summiteer), Ronnie Robb,
Angus Andrew and Alison Hargreaves ( Alison was officially on a separate
expedition -the Ferrino Everest Lady Alone- but was very closely attached to the
B.M.E.M.E. and was part financed by the Expedition and is therefore included).
Liaison Officer: Mr Gongal, Ministry of Tourism, H.M.G.Nepal.
High Altitude Sherpas were: Kilu Temba (Sirdar), Dorje (summiteer x 5), Dawa
Temba (summiteer), Tensing, Kami Rita and Finjo. All except Kilu Temba had
summited Everest on previous occasions.
The post monsoon season of 1994 was a little unusual in that the monsoon
persisted until September 23rd (officially) and the Jet stream winds commenced
on October the first. It was the strong , cold winds that thwarted most of the
other teams on the mountain.
We commenced work in the Icefall on September 1st as stipulated by the terms
of our permit. The monsoon snow meant that the Icefall was in relatively benign
condition and we made rapid progress to Camp 1 and required relatively few
ladders in the process. As the season progressed fresh crevasses opened up and
seracs collapsed obliterating our route. By the end of the Expedition many
sections of the Icefall route were completely unrecognisable and we had deployed
all 61 of the ladders hired from Asian Trekking - the ladders were retrieved by
the Icefall Sherpas after the Expedition and were kept in Gorak Shep for the
next season.
Poor visibility and frequent avalanches in the Western Cwm delayed our
progress and we used much of this time to stock Camp 1. The conditions in mid
September meant that we lost several crucial days before we could establish Camp
2 and thus we became established there a little later than we had hoped for. A
large avalanche on the Lhotse Face engulfed Ronnie Robb and Henry Todd
(International Lhotse Team) but fortunately they were relatively unscathed.
Statistically ascents take place from September 26th onwards and we had
originally planned to be in position on the South Col for a summit bid during
the last week of September. Indeed, had we been a few days ahead we would have
encountered far less severe conditions as the last 5 days of September were both
clear and calm. By the time we had stocked Camp 4 our first possible date for a
summit bid was October 3rd and we made our plans for that date. Unfortunately
this summit bid had to be further delayed due to Ronnie's illness (cerebral
oedema). As it turned out October 3rd would have been an impossible summit day
due to extreme winds. On this day the International Lhotse Team got into severe
trouble 150 metres below the summit of Lhotse.
Camp 4 was occupied shortly afterwards but a serious summit bid was precluded
due to the weather and shortages of food and fuel. Some members remained at Camp
4 attempting to sit out the storm whilst others descended to bide their time.
The weather moderated slightly on the 9th ,10th and 11th of October giving the
only window of opportunity. Andrew Pollard made his solo bid on the 9th turning
around at 8,600m metres due to difficult snow conditions and a shortage of
oxygen. The Japanese team made their ascent on the 10th and Charlie Hornsby and
Roddy Kirkwood went on the 11th.. Alison, Angus and the French Team were poised
to go on the 12th but by now the winds were back to full force and only Alison
ventured above Camp 4. Angus remained at Camp 4 for a few more days but the
winds never moderated.
Our Sherpas refused to assist in the clearance of the mountain and so much of
this work was done by the Icefall Sherpas, the French Sherpas and the 2
remaining ones loyal to us. Base Camp was dismantled on 15th and the climbing
and research teams flew from Syanboche on the 17th and 18th.
It is difficult to know how we would improve on our tactics in the future. We
pushed towards Camp 2 with reasonable haste but the delay in our arrival made
the summit bid all the more difficult. If we had been in a position to climb
from the South Col during September then I am sure at least another 3 members
would have reached the summit. Poor Sherpa leadership and relations certainly
contributed to this delay and it is possible that with a better Sirdar, a more
willing team and perhaps another couple of High Altitude porters we would have
been in position a few crucial days earlier. We tried to be reasonably
meticulous in packaging loads but in retrospect we should have sent all loads
above Base Camp in pre-packed, locked containers as this would have avoided the
problems of pilfering (particularly of food) and "down-sizing" by Sherpas. We
left much of the day to day management of loads and record keeping up to our
Sirdar who clearly was not up to the job but this was a difficult management
problem. Our own lack of experience of recruiting and managing high altitude
Sherpas undoubtedly compounded our problems and future teams would be well
advised to research the backgrounds of their key personnel fully seeking, where
possible, personal recommendations.
Having made these observations the French and Japanese teams progressed at
the same rate on the mountain as us despite their lavish Sherpa : Climber ratios
and their apparently excellent teamwork. Our Sherpas did more than their share
of the route making whilst the other teams stocked their camps. Of all the
climbing teams on Everest ours was undoubtedly the strongest and this must be
partially due to the fact that our team did much of their own load carrying
whilst the others relied exclusively on their Sherpas.
Table of Contents
Pumori Climbing Report:
I have not received a report from the Pumori team but have written down what I
know of their ascent. I apologise in advance if the details are sketchy or
inaccurate.
Team members: Chris Comerie (Leader and summiteer), Edi Albert, Paul Cleary (summiteer),
Ian Newberry, Mark Bryan (summiteer)
The Pumori team were delayed for 5 days in Kathmandu due to poor flying
weather. Once on the trek their luck fared little better when half of the team
fell ill with a severe flu like illness. The fit half pressed on in order to
avoid contracting the same illness and began establishing Base Camp and
preparing the route to Camp 1. Despite these early misfortunes they made rapid
progress.
Although the route is technically demanding they were accompanied by a dog ("Shep"
as in Gorak") as far as Camp 1. On its arrival there it completely flaked out
and the team's logistical problems were compounded by the need for dog food at
Camp 1. The dog's condition at Camp 1 gave cause for concern and Mark Bryan (a
veterinarian) contemplated the prospect of euthanasia but fortunately it rallied
and was later carried down in a rucksack. The team shared the route fixing with
other teams on the Mountain and survived, unscathed, frequent avalanches on the
face.
They placed a snow hole on the ridge and Mark Bryan and Paul Cleary went
first to the summit. Edi Albert and Chris Comerie moved up to make their bid the
next day but Edi became ill in the night and probably suffered some degree of
cerebral oedema. Edi descended and Chris went alone to the summit in excellent
conditions.
Despite early illness and delays they climbed a difficult and dangerous route
quickly and efficiently without mishap.
Support Group Climbing Reports
Support Group Leader: Stuart McNeil. There were 68 members of the Support
Group and 8 members of the Everest climbing team. The activities of the Support
Group were too diverse to summarise in a single report so I have listed the
ascents made and leave it to the accounts in the "Personal Observations" section
to give a fuller account of what went on.
Thirty five members of the Support Group arrived in Kathmandu on September
5th where they were unfortunately delayed for 5 days due to bad weather. The
remainder arrived on September 19th. The earlier Table shows how their
activities were kept separate in time and place in order to minimise
over-crowding and consequent environmental impact. The Support Groups consisted
of a broad cross section of experience, abilities and ambitions. Despite this
there were no serious compatibility problems, no mishaps and a substantial
number of ascents were made.
For descriptions of member's experiences click below
Table of Contents
Accounts of the exploits of individual members of British Mount Everest
Medical Expedition 1994
Personal Observations:
I have asked all members of the Expedition to write on any aspect of the trip
however controversial. These are the contributions that I have received.
Impressions of Everest
by John Sanders
Daylight slits like a razor across Base Camp but I can't
rouse from my bag before the sun's warmth and Diana's smiling aqua Koflachs and
the tea she brings come. A rest day otherwise by now we would have skated across
frosted boulders under a star filled sky cut from the gowns of Vegas show girls
into the Icefall maze too beautiful and too uphill to be scary. Drifting in and
out of fantasy passes the time on the carry and in the tent. Staring at her
picture I write to my girlfriend thousands of miles away and dreaming of a
friendly and familiar body wish the photograph would turn to smoke so I could
inhale her.
For days foodless and wind sheared we sit on the south Col. Familiarity has
stripped the Sherpas of their gilded reputation. Not cheerful carefree nobles;
they are people too. Are they card playing jokers always with a gap-tooth smile
or are they petty, angry and jealous? Appearances change quickly and reliability
is important in the mountains. A battle rages between what we want and what we
see putting tension in the fabric of the group. We have all read of and want to
believe in selfless, hardworking mountain companions, but see whores who do only
their job quickly and that without love or completeness.
Summits bestow their favours with tears, jewelled tears that flow so fast
they need two hands to catch: Andy's South East Ridge tears for his baby Jamie;
Roddy and Charlie's tears of ecstasy and relief, two Sisyphes freed and
triumphant; Ronnie's stroke crippled, lop- sided face in laboured sobs of fear
and loss. Rich emotions and mortar between friends that we would not trade. We
sacrifice so much for the pain, to satisfy our sweet tooth and feel the shared
joy of travel in the mountains. Chasing a shadowy love we exorcise our desire
and chase the point. How do we know when to love and when to quit?
Foodless on the South Col and taking an incomplete gear inventory in
Kathmandu we think polluting thoughts and find it is our companions and the
mountains that are really important. Idolising the mountains, we think it is the
summit we want and do not realise it is some ethereal combination of snow on
rock, laughter with friends, shared moods and dreams that we crave. The
deception is part of it too. Satisfied, for now, we go home no one having made
the only possible wrong decision - the one that leaves an empty seat on the
plane. Filled with stories we return to our other loves, but when we can say "I
was scared" but can no longer retrieve the feeling of fear we will return.
John Sanders is a paediatric anaesthetist.
****
When did it Start? BMEME 1990 - 1994
by John Nathan
We came, we saw, some conquered. I read that people go to the Himalayas to be
gobsmacked. I was totally gobsmacked for weeks, but for me the Expedition
started long before the autumn of 1994.
It started in January 1993 when I rang Simon and was accepted as a member.
From that moment onwards my life changed completely. Suddenly I was rushing 250
miles to North Wales for a weekend medical course, where I was rubbing shoulders
with mountaineers of world renown. This was, as the Americans say, 'sumthin
else'. I was discussing research projects, seeing pictures of the Vallot Hut
(ONLY ?! 4,000 metres), having lectures on frostbite, oo-er!
My colleagues tolerantly allowed me to change my duty weekends, and I soon
found myself driving 500 miles to Scotland for the weekend (in the rain). I well
remember climbing Ben Nevis by the tourist track, and feeling quite pleased with
myself that in snowy, foggy conditions my companions and I reached the top by 1
p.m., the pre-arranged meeting time. We opened the McInnes biscuit tin that sits
on the top of the mountain, only to see Charlie, Simon and Stuart who had
climbed the vertical side quicker than we had walked up the easy side.
I remember wondering what on earth I was doing at Pen y Pass at 5 am one
August morning (in the rain) and mist, with 3 others to try to climb all the
Welsh 3,000 'ers, and I also remember the fear of seeing the arrete of Crib Goch
in the half light of dawn, all wet and slippery. I cannot describe the joy of
seeing Tony with a cup of tea at his van after we had climbed the first 3.
I remember driving northwards again to Oldham in October (in the rain), and
arriving exhausted at 10.30 p.m. after trying to follow the Oldham team's map
which was perfect except that half the roads were missing from it! However, they
got together with the famous Herbie and made that another magical weekend. (You
remember the Oldham team in Nepal; they were the ones who were usually seen
running when some of us found difficulty walking). There was another weekend in
Derbyshire in January, when we found ourselves in a farmyard with cowshit just a
fraction deeper than the top of our boots. In February I drove to Fort William
again (in the rain). Conditions there, as it turned out, were colder than the
Himalayas, and I well remember Ronnie insisting on putting up his broken tent in
a gale underneath the Snowgoose Restaurant, 10 feet from a warm indoor shelter.
In April, a group of us went ski touring in the Jungfrau region. I remember
well toiling up the Jungfrau Glacier in the heat one day, then the very next day
struggling to find an Alpine Hut in a snowstorm.
Then in June we were all together in a mountain hut in North Wales (in the
rain), and I was wondering whether George's little dog would water the end of a
sleeping bag during the night. I have heard exactly who snores and who farts all
night, and I am sure that I don't do either!
I am sure that there will be amazing stories about the Khumbu, but for me the
period beforehand took me into places I have never been before in our own
country. This, as well as the Himalayas, (not in the rain), will live with me
for ever.
PS Does the sun shine in North Wales and Scotland?
John Nathan is a General Practitioner in Surrey.
****
The Announcement!
by Christine Smith
The group sat waiting in the small darkened room. The yaks were late - were
they lost or just overdue? With no tents there was nothing to do but sit
patiently. Eyes shifted tiredly around the room. This house was different to the
others we had seen, an old Sherpa house with the cattle shed below. There was
little light filtering in, the walls were blackened by years of smoke. Ornate
copper pots lined the shelf opposite and the family altar stood proudly at the
far end. Our rucksacks leaned against the central pillar, below the soot marks
counting the passing years. Sherpa voices drifted from the yak byre below and
nearby the kitchen. We decided to try the Kukhri rum. We sat quietly thinking
about the past weeks and the Parchamo climb to come.
A voice broke the silence, something prompted Martin to think of the time and
the radio schedule at 6 p.m.. No one was particularly interested - we'd been out
of contact for several days now- still it was worth a try. Looks of surprise
ensued when seconds later the radio burst into life, Base Camp was calling other
stations. We tried to reply, but to no avail. We listened with growing interest
as the clear tone of Simon's voice urged teams to respond. Something in his
speech expressed a sense of urgency - did he have something important to say? He
had no way of knowing we were listening. We were powerless. We could only will
him to continue transmissions.
Everyone was more alert now and hoping for any news - it had been strange
without communications for so long. To everyone's relief Simon's slightly
agitated voice finally declared that he would transmit a blind message. Then as
everyone leaned forward expectantly, the radio fell silent. Faces around the
room showed the same thoughts; had there been an accident, was it bad news or
was it summit success? The tension began to rise as voices quietly began to
ponder.
The radio broke through the chatter and again everyone leaned towards it in
anticipation. The Sherpas began to gather in the doorway, sensing the occasion.
"Base Camp will be transmitting blind to all stations in the Khumbu". The
message was repeated. The suspense grew and then the adrenaline really began to
surge. Silence fell again. The room was filled with loud chattering this time as
everyone willed Simon to make the announcement.
The next few minutes seemed an age. We were powerless to do anything but
wait. Then the news came. Short but loud and clear. "Two members of the team
have reached the summit of Mount Everest". Loud cheers broke the tension. The
tranquillity of the Khumbu was momentarily shattered. They'd done it! Who'd done
it? The cheers and excited chattering rose and fell as everyone applauded the
success and simultaneously craved more information. It was another day before
that came (and even then it was by a process of elimination!).
The Expedition could go home proud in the knowledge that its highest goal had
been reached. Only now did we realise how much we had all wanted this success.
As the excitement turned again to calm and the adrenaline levels subsided, the
team celebrated in the style they knew best. A toast to the Expedition, its
leader and to the mystery climbers. The lodge was soon out of rum! New thoughts
began to dawn. Now we had to succeed on Parchamo!
Christine Smith is a school teacher near Manchester and was the Spokesperson for
Group 1.
****
Names
By Ian Baxter
Group 4 included Stuart McNeil, Neil Crossling and me (Ian Baxter). I have
noticed a tendency in the past to confuse Neil and Ian but Stuart is harder to
explain. In any case we were for ever calling each other by the wrong name and I
was probably the worst offender. Various solutions were mooted including writing
names across the respective foreheads in indelible ink but they were never acted
upon.. One morning I found myself walking behind Stuart and must have addressed
him as Neil on a dozen occasions in as many minutes. Quite reasonably he
remonstrated with me in the course of a good natured rollicking. Three and a
half seconds later HE called ME Neil!
Ian Baxter is a policeman in Aberdeen
****
Summit Day
by Charlie Hornsby
Back again, home sweet home. The two Wild Country tents had
not been blown away after all, perhaps more battered, a few tears, but still
there. Oxygen bottles haphazardly scattered by the wind about this inhospitable,
sastrugied wasteland, clattering together in a noisy rhythm. A cold and eternal
wind whipped across the South Col. Drunk from hypoxia, exhausted and tired, I
stood to take in the atmosphere of this amazing place. Wonderment and respect
for the landscape but once more despair as our hopes and dreams blew off towards
Tibet.
Several hundred metres behind me, Rod and Alison appeared on
the horizon rounding the wind-slabbed convexity of the Geneva Spur; like me
moving slowly but methodically towards the Col. Long shadows now. An even longer
summit plume trailed to the North East, and to the west the sky-scape an
explosion of soft colour heralding the day's end and a cold night ahead.
The three of us quite comfortably squeezed into one tent, big Dorje and wee
Dawa into the other, communication between the two tents impossible despite
their proximity. The time was set - rendezvous outside at mid night. Long night
hours lay ahead, we settled down with numbed acceptance.
Peering out through the doorway I traced the line of the "Voi Normale" across
the deeply reddening South face, the snow plumes beautifully illuminated by the
last of the light. Two slowly moving figures caught my eye approaching through
the veils of spin-drift; a wave and soon an oxygen masked face before us -
Nukita - summit boy! Wide grins, warm congratulations and handshakes; tales of
adventure. I wondered how he must feel now?
The three of us alone again, huddled into double dacron bags for warmth,
actually quite comfortable until we moved; then melting hoarfrost would run in
rivulet's down the tent fabric to dampen us further. Alison's tower stove swayed
awkwardly on its suspension but its soft purr efficiently provided a steady
supply of warm drinks. I was surprised to feel pangs of hunger. The intensity of
the wind and the rattle of the tent gradually increased, along with my anxiety
and tension. Not so much a fear but rather a feeling of hopelessness with our
situation, wondering whether chances were ebbing away. But up here emotions were
strangely blunted. I struggled to rationalise in the oxygen depleted atmosphere.
Midnight crept slowly by and Rod, geared up, chanced a look outside into the
funnelling void of wind and spin-drift. Perhaps it wouldn't be so bad when we
were up and out of here? He disappeared into the night to consult the two
sherpas. Minutes later back with a committing expression - Dorje and Dawa were
ready and inpatient to leave, dollar signs alight in their eyes. Cynical
perhaps, these "barrow boys" of the Khumbu.
Struggling with crampons and rucksack. The claustrophobia constraint of an
oxygen mask; should I take my ski poles? I sensed the impatience of the others
and yet I did not feel prepared, even after so much waiting. Then we were away
into the darkness, me racing against my breath to catch up - no rhythm, feeling
tired and strangely removed.
The incline of the slope increased quickly, sastrugi ridges tripping me and
clumsy boots breaking through the islands of crust - this was exhausting
although I was acutely aware of our limited oxygen supply and loath to crank up
the flow. One litre per minute, struggling on into the night.
We gained ground, slowly, but definitely higher; joy to be out of that
blasted wind. Able to think again, warm and more comfortable. The snow surface
improved, now supporting our weight, neve like as we weaved upward via ramps and
narrow couloirs. I was enjoying the movement. Ahead the twin head torch beams of
Dorje and Dawa could be picked out intermittently. So this was Everest.
I am not quite sure when I first became aware of the dull glow in the eastern
sky. Subtly, I began to pick out the rock features around me, the bulk of Lhotse
behind, Makalu, and over there , that must be Kanchenjunga, a distant
silhouette. The slope ahead widened out into a broad couloir and we cramponed
steadily up its icy steepness.
Heavy breathing, slow rhythmic steps, many rests, but the crest of the South
East Ridge was now close above us. Dorje and Dawa catching the first rays of the
new day as they rested in the dawn stillness. Back to plod mode, not allowing my
mind to travel too far, concentrating only on this moment, and then the
next.....
The ridge at last and time to rest a while as the soft morning glow
highlighted this beautiful ocean of mountains. The westward peaks of Cho Oyo and
Pumori, Nuptse and Lhotse with its distinctive summit couloir and to the north
the soft pastels of the high Tibetan Plateau. Below us, the Kanchung glacier a
sea of contrasting shades and textures. We sat silently in awe, glad to be free
of the uncomfortable masks for a while.
The South East Ridge curving up gracefully toward the South Summit, gentle at
first, then finally rearing up in climax - quite steep and rocky. We changed
cylinders, stashing another in readiness for descent. Moving quite easily now in
the warmth of the sun.
The angle steepened, not very steep but sufficiently so to climb with great
care. The snow surface changed, now quite soft and un-consolidated overlying
loose, shaley rock, the bedding plane of which slanted awkwardly downwards. We
moved to the very crest of the ridge, heading for the extra security of the rock
there, in places adorned by straggled and frayed rope dubiously anchored and
treated with extreme caution. Absorbing climbing as the Kanchung Face unfolded
below our feet, eight thousand feet to its base.
Before us lay the South Summit. the wind had picked up and, worryingly,
rather "funky" looking clouds had gathered above the summit ridge -"hog's
backs". Snapped out of our time warp thoughts, Rod and I were apprehensive,
success appeared almost tangible although I sensed a creeping anxiety that our
great prize would be snatched from our grasp. Spurred on, we moved purposefully
towards the waiting calls of the sherpas on the South Summit, only some 50
metres further. Several of Nukita's discarded oxygen cylinders marked the way.
Rounding the icy crest, suddenly a familiar picture in the frame before us,
not déjà vu I told myself rationally. The scene that I had studied so many times
in so many photographs in so many books - the summit ridge itself. Just as I had
expected it to appear, the narrow arrete studded with Nukita's pigeon hole steps
leading to the foot of the short, rocky Hillary Step. To my left, the steep
South Summit gully - I felt instant respect for those men of 1975.
Reunited with Dorje and Dawa, we took shelter below a short steep wall just
below the South Summit. The wind was tearing across the arrete ahead, obviously
very strong as an almost horizontal plume of snow and cloud streaked off into
Tibet. The prospect of the exposed ridge before us appeared suddenly daunting -
apprehension drifted over me. I looked to Dawa, he was scared too, but was
already dragging a 6 mm rope from his sack; I did the same.
Although communication was difficult, we signalled to one another. I tied on
and, with the crudest of belays, scuttled off on all fours along the knife edge
ridge, wind blasting me from the side. A tangle in the rope - perching
precariously "a cheval" across the arrete, I fumbled with a surprising lack of
dexterity with this "bird's nest". Of all places for this to happen! I gave up
and cut the rope, rejoining the ends with a simple granny knot. The rope came
taught but already Dawa was following behind using the rope as a hand-rail. He
soon passed by, on to tackle the alarmingly unstable looking final ridge with
gung-ho gusto. No disasters - Dawa was there and quickly secured his rope to an
old rope to an old line dangling from this famous rocky step. Together we
cramponed up with remarkable ease; although steep, the snow was firm and a
narrow gully twisted through this final obstacle leading the way to the easy
slopes beyond. We had turned the last key to success. The four of us moved on
upwards.
"Just a walk now" I told myself although I could clearly see giant cornices
overhanging the Kanchung face to the right. Was this really it? Were we really
going to climb the Big One? I looked back to Rod and raised a clenched mitt with
an overwhelming feeling of joyful emotion. I stooped, gasping and breathless
over my ice axe and my eyes filled with tears. Far away faces I knew and loved.
Moving along the top of the world together Rod and I, Dorje and Dawa, an
experience I had never allowed myself to imagine before. Perhaps a safeguard
mechanism against the trauma of failure? Now my mind was free at last and the
summit only a few feet away. I felt a deep feeling of relief, contentment and
emotion, we had made it.
Standing on the top of the world, summited, ticked, bagged. How lucky I was
to feel so alive and to feel the strength of the bond between us? I thought of
the others at Base Camp, of Simon and of Ronnie now back home; it had been an
incredible trip and we had succeeded.
Six weeks later I sit at a desk on another dreary November afternoon, tied to
a bleep in a dull hospital. Alone again now, I remember the moments that I can
never forget and wonder what this life's all about?
Charlie Hornsby is GP in Elgin.
****
GORAK SHEP TO BASE CAMP
by George Wormald
It was rather as travelling to a friend's party on a Friday night before a
Bank Holiday - we knew it would be a pain but it had to be done. The journey was
tedious, tiring and frustrating - how could it take so long? The route was stop
start with queues forming on the steep slopes, and changes in direction where
the way had to be changed. Occasionally there was the detritus of previous
travellers rising to the surface. We had anticipated it to be a two hour journey
but it was only after four hours that we came within sight of our destination.
Everyone was thoroughly hot, exhausted and fed up.
The final straw was the last stage where we were crawling in first gear along
a narrow switchback - so close and yet so far away from our destination that
tantalisingly came into view every now and again. It was nearly dusk when we
arrived, surprised at the number of people at the party and the noise coming
from the green building. We were late arrivals, what would we find, who would be
there so hesitatingly we entered.................
What a welcome from mine hosts Pete, Dave, Cathy and company. Stories were
recounted of the trek, what was happening on the Hill, the who, what, when and
why. It was just like gate crashing because our tightly knit group was now
thrust into the hustle and bustle of a new world.
It was more like being in the racing pits at Silverstone. People coming and
going, progress of the elite to follow, scanning the skyline through the
binoculars, and reports of close shaves with the unthinkable. The adrenaline
would flow when the radio crackled to life. News from the climbers on the Hill
bringing us up to date with what was happening beyond the Icefall - so close yet
so far away.
New people to meet - what was their name, what experiments were they doing,
which expedition did they belong to? - then there were changed routines and new
pecking orders, even new jokes to replace our tired and much overused ones of
the trek in. However after a while it felt like home and a realisation that we
had achieved one of the major goals of our expedition.
George Wormald is a business manager at Axis.
****
Adventure of a lifetime
by Victoria Weller
Culture shock! Adjustment! We had left the relatively familiar confines of
the airport and were transported into another world, no longer seen through the
lens of a TV camera, but through the open windows of a taxi hurtling through the
dusty uneven streets, lined with a multitude of shops glimpsed beneath
corrugated iron roofs.
Images flashed past of old men outside the dukas drinking sweet milk tea; of
washing lines slung between buildings; of small boys animatedly trying to sell
fruit; all amid the perpetual sounding of car horns and the clattering of
rickshaws and the three wheeled tuk-tuks.
The plan was to go to Kathmandu, take a bus to the end of the road, and then
trek for about two weeks to the Everest base Camp. After a few hectic days in
the capital the first ten days of the trek were fantastic. On a typical day we
would wake early and set off at around 7 am and walk until lunch, taken at a tea
house at about midday.
They say that the first few days trekking exhausts everyone to begin with: I
would certainly vouch for the truth of the guide-book description of our walk
as, "very strenuous". Having managed to get places on the tourist bus, that is
to say one where there is only one person per seat, we began the nine hour ride
to Jiri.
I noted with interest that there was a button on the dash-board to indicate
the brake failure. This would light up periodically as if to remind us that it
still had a useful function. Eventually, after many rehearsals, the bus broke
down for the last time at dusk, 13 km from our destination and we had to go on
by foot. The sky grew darker and darker and as my friend and I were walking
slowly with our heavy packs we became separated from our fellow passengers.
Unexpectedly we were beckoned to the side of the road by a Nepalese peasant
family. A little anxiously I descended the rough path to their house where they
invited us to spend the night. This generosity was one of many such displays of
warmth and kindness we were shown throughout the trek.
That night we sat on the mud floor, around the fire in their kitchen, and
joined them in a meal of boiled potatoes with salt and chilli and rice. It is
surprising how quickly one learns a language when one is hungry. The following
day we walked on to Jiri where we hired a porter and guide for our trek to
Everest.
After so much bad publicity last year, I expected the trail to be littered
with pink loo paper and other western debris. Admittedly I went before the
tourist season was underway, but I was struck by the fact that the countryside
was so clean. Kathmandu is a different kettle of fish. It is a sprawling city,
full of great poverty, and the entire waste from the capital seems to be
deposited in the river. Conversely, on the trek only an occasional loo in a
lodge emptied into the river. The others were holes in the ground, which may not
have been altogether pleasing, but at least they were environmentally sound. It
was difficult to balance the facts that, as a tourist, one is contributing to a
weak economy but at the same time encouraging the Nepalese to exploit their
landscape. Not surprisingly they have a great desire to build tea houses of
timber, which are frequently in groups, to benefit directly from each annual
influx of visitors. However, it was reassuring to see that thousands of
seedlings were being prepared for planting in the Sagarmartha National Park.
Despite the scars left by the axes of the ambitious, much forest remains and
still covers a landscape which is beautiful and breathtaking in its variety.
From lush, verdant hillsides filled with fascinating flowers and strange sounds
one moved into a different world at higher altitude. The scenery became rocky,
harsh and silent, with sparse vegetation. The weather was clear and cool with
blue skies and brilliant stars by night.
After 15 days walking , at the highest point of the trek, lies a hill of
5,500 metres, called Kala Pattar. From there it is a spectacular and rewarding
view. One looks down onto clear, reflected blue lakes on one side, rocky moraine
on another, and then, towering majestically above, there are the magnificent,
awe-inspiring, snowy peaks of several of the highest mountains in the world -
one of which is Everest.
My admiration for those who attempt to climb the great mountain, with or
without oxygen, has increased 10 fold. As we came down from Kala Pattar there is
50% less oxygen than at sea level, we remembered and understood another trekker
who was inspired there to compose songs about what he had seen.
In the final four hours of our journey to Base Camp, at 5,300 metres, the
change in landscape was dramatic and utterly removed from anything I had ever
imagined. We slowly crossed the glacier before us, which was made up of acres
and acres of huge boulders and scree on an icy bed.
There were vast seracs created by the glacial flow beneath forcing up ice
mountains, and many of the boulders were perched high on great, frozen wedges.
The path was barely discernible, marked by an occasional cairn or pile of yak
dung, and along it we picked our way to the welcome lying beyond desolation.
The British Expedition's Base Camp was immaculate. Contrary to what has been
reported in the world's press there were none of the piles of used oxygen
cylinders, frozen bodies and waste described in the tabloids. Impressive
arrangements had been made for the disposal of all human and material detritus,
as one would expect from a well organised and serious research expedition.
The work that was being carried out for many weeks was thorough, detailed and
well controlled. I was glad to be used as a guinea-pig for some scientific
research during my visit. Amongst other projects the Expedition expects to
produce much positive information on the effects of altitude on the body, which
cannot be ascertained by air travel by plane or balloon for example. A valuable
contribution to our knowledge of mountain sickness will certainly be one of many
results that emerges.
To go to Nepal is an eye-opening experience for a molly-coddled westerner. We
are aware of third world poverty from the media. To see the reality and reflect
on one's own good fortune is quite another thing. To wonder what can or should
be done in the world is something else still.
Now, when I consider Nepal, my mind will flick through a book of images it
retains. Among the selection will be not only those of poverty, but also of the
scenery, the welcoming faces of the Nepalese people, the gurgling laughter of a
baby I met, and all the other sounds and smells of a beautiful and fascinating
country.
Victoria Weller is taking a year off between 'A' levels and university. She
trekked independently from Jiri and joined the Expedition at Base Camp.
****
Swimming at 17,000 feet
By Ken Stewart
At Gorak Shep (alias Lake Camp) I jokingly suggested a swim in the lake to
Sherpa Santash. He took me seriously so I had to go in. So then had he. The
water was cold but not as freezing as anticipated. The rapid breathing was hard
to control; but this soon settled and then the dip was "almost" enjoyable. It
didn't last long though. We swam about 25 yards and then out we came, cleaner
than before, and really chuffed with ourselves. We had to repeat the dip every
time we passed Gorak Shep so had 3 more!
Ken Stewart, when he's not off his trolley, is a gynaecologist in Stirling.
****
Everest - Next Time?
By Andrew Pollard
When I woke up again, if I had ever been asleep, it was getting light. The
tent was still ravaged by the wind and the demented flapping of the fabric was
unchanged, its continuing presence almost reassuring. The inner tent was coated
in frost which was sprinkled onto me whenever I moved or the thundering wind
shook the tent. My down suit was damp with condensation and my socks wet and
cold. This was the fourth day at Camp IV on the South Col at 8000m without food
and since yesterday I was alone.
For those four days the Col had been shrouded in cloud and the icy wind blew
snow around with the intent of burying all of our equipment, which it did. The
others had left to try their chances on a later day and the Sherpas had deserted
me. It was desperately cold. I was using oxygen continuously now to suppress the
lethargy, cold and physical debility, which was so overwhelming. During several
finger-numbing forays through the tent door, it was becoming increasingly
difficult to find full oxygen cylinders buried in the snow outside and I knew it
was time to go down. Condensation pooled in my oxygen mask and trickled down my
chin, my throat ached from coughing. Time passed easily though, I don't remember
much detail of my mental musings, the lack of oxygen slowed thought and melting
snow for drinking-water took all day.
But something was different this morning. I got to my knees and unzipped the
tent a fraction in what seemed like a frenzy of breathless activity. A shower of
fine snow blew in my face and I shivered. But it was glorious. The sky was blue
and cloudless for the first time and the South Summit of Everest was visible and
crowned golden with the early sun. The wind was still roaring out there but less
snow streamed across the Col and the slopes in front of me up to the South East
Ridge seemed calm. It was 9th October 1994.
After 2 squares of chocolate and a sip of almost frozen Isostar, I set off
towards Everest. I don't remember why, or what I had intended, but I had three 3
Litre oxygen cylinders in my rucksack and a litre of fluid. The oxygen was set
at 2 litres per minute. I decided I wanted to have a closer look at Everest and
take some photos. But I didn't know where to go. I could see the South Summit
and South East Ridge but there were too many possible approaches up the slopes
to the ridge. I never imagined I would be alone here. I was scared.
The snow was horrible. Most of the slope up to the ridge was wind-slab - a
thick hard crust resting on unconsolidated snow. Each step was treacherous. I
either fell through the crust and stumbled or slid on the slab. A few small
avalanches set off from my feet and I wished I had a longer axe. There had been
no wind since I left the South Col and I was warm as long as I was moving. I
felt good. Icicles hung from my chin and my toes were numb.
Suddenly I couldn't breathe. I thought I was being choked. I gasped and
gasped. It slowly dawned on me that my oxygen cylinder must be empty. It was
steep here and I couldn't safely take off my rucksack and get out a new one. I
struggled on with pain in my chest, pain from sucking at the thin air. After an
age I reached some rocks where I could rest before fumbling with the regulator
and a new cylinder and begin gulping in life.
Sooner than I thought, I was just below the Ridge and pressed on straight up.
Ten metres further and the snow became more unconsolidated. Like climbing on
polystyrene beads. No upward progress. I turned the oxygen up to 3 litres per
minute. I felt very insecure and traversed for half an hour plunging my axe deep
into the snow with every side step until, eventually, I found good purchase and
I stood on the South East Ridge of Everest.
The snow on the Ridge was the same. In places it narrowed and my slipping and
stumbling threatened to hurl me down into Tibet or back to the South Col. Soon
enough, though, the angle eased and I sat down on a flat section below the last
slope up to the South Summit. I was at 8600m.
It is a remarkable place. I looked across to the summit of Lhotse, over Nuptse
to the Mountains of Nepal and North and East into the brown plateau of Tibet.
Below I could see the tents on the South Col. Red dots in the snow. I took off
my oxygen mask and realised I was very alone. To my astonishment, I heard John
talking on the radio from Base Camp. The friendly sound was deeply comforting
and a wave of emotion swept over. I longed to speak to him and I talked
frantically into the handset but he could not hear me and I felt rejected. It
was about 11.00 am
I was within an hour of the South Summit of Everest and looking up I could
almost touch it. I felt physically strong but the snow conditions were still
unpleasant and dangerous and I was concerned about the descent. I was on my own,
high on Everest with so much to lose. I began to sob. Not outwardly. There was
no one to see anyway. Suddenly, it all began to seem so intensely pitifully
pointless. I began to think of my son. Jamie was five and a half months old when
I left and I cried at the loss of three months of his life. I missed Rachel
desperately and wondered how I ever came to be sitting on this crazy frozen
perch looking down on the world. So I got up, turned my back on Everest and went
home.
It'll be Christmas Eve tomorrow. Jamie is quiet again now, tummy full of milk.
Lying in his cot warm and snuggled under cosy blankets, his breathing is
peaceful and content, hair ruffled and long eyelashes locked in sleep. Outside
it's -6oC and there is ice on the window pane and a thick frost on the ground in
the blackest night. Rachel is asleep too, deep in the duvet. It's 5.30 am and
it's cold, but this is where I want to be tonight, with my wife and my boy.
Andrew Pollard is a research fellow in paediatric infectious diseases.
****
Clerical and Medical
By John Currin
With three days to go and the house strewn with blue plastic barrels and various
piles of gear, the phone calls from newspapers, radio and TV suddenly came thick
and fast. Feeling a little intimidated by the proposed TV coverage in my local
gym whose infrequent use I now regretted I sought some support from my closest
fellow expeditioner Chris Comerie. Having lifted some very light weights for the
cameras I returned from the changing room just in time to hear the last part of
Chris' interview. After some questions relating to climbing objectives and
preparation the interviewer said "Tell me Chris why should a climbing expedition
want to take a clergyman along?" I think Chris and I had met just once before at
the Lloyd's event and this question was clearly one he had not anticipated.
Searching for an answer while making some very diplomatic comments he finally
said, "Well he'll come in very useful if someone gets killed."
We began the trek to Base Camp at Lukla in conditions of low cloud and
drizzle. The weather remained more or less the same over the next four days, by
which time we had taken a rest day in Namche and pressed on to Tengboche. The
following morning I remember waking to bright sunshine, the sound of excited
voices and tent zips being hurriedly opened. Suddenly after spending the last
few days trekking in typical and all too familiar Lakeland conditions, that day
we were presented with a full and glorious panorama of towering crystal white
peaks, soaring into cloudless blue skies. In the warmth of the morning sun I
shared the conviction of the Psalmist who said "The heavens declare the glory of
God; the skies the work of his hands." During the previous days of cloud and
rain I had heard no one complain. In fact I think all of us were relieved to be
free from the confines of Kathmandu,. As I gazed around and at last saw, what I
had long anticipated, the clarity of the light, the tranquillity of the morning
and the majesty of the peaks far exceeded my expectations. For a while that
morning we were all awed and subdued.
I am more than grateful that there was no need to officiate in the way Chris
had mentioned. Although a little disappointed and frustrated that due to ill
health my own mountaineering objectives were not realised but the trekking was
unforgettable and enhanced by warm companionship and strong team spirit. I know
the experience the summit team had with the high altitude Sherpas was to say the
least mixed, but the Sherpas who accompanied Group One and also Nima with whom I
left Jill and the children were excellent. I found them to be organised,
reliable, industrious, trustworthy and uncomplaining. Their kindness and
hospitality has left as profound an influence on me as did the impact of being
amidst the worlds highest mountains.
John Currin is a Curate at Eastwood Church
****
Our rest day!
By Denzil Broadhurst
The calm, measured tones of David Collier, the research co-ordinator, came
over the radio from Everest Base camp. "Ronnie's had a stroke at camp 1 and we
may need you to help"
OK, so we were members of a rescue team, but we hadn't really expected to be
needed. Simon had asked us some time ago if we would act as a rescue team whilst
we were with the expedition. Of course we laughingly agreed, knowing that we
were only going to be in base camp for the two brief periods whilst tests were
being done, the rest of the time we would be trekking, or climbing elsewhere, so
the chances of us being in the right place at the right time seemed somewhat
remote.
We'd been up to Base Camp for our first 5 days of medical tests to give some
pre-acclimatisation readings, and then trekked down to attempt Lobuje East,
eventually being defeated by thigh deep sugar snow at about 5700 metres. The
prospect of the route ahead being a few hours of dangerous navigation through
some desperate looking seracs and snow bridges hadn't been very encouraging
anyway.
We'd then moved on to Dingboche to start the trek up to Island Peak, and the
plans for the day were a gentle stroll up to Chukhung. We'd originally planned
to have a rest day, but with the time lost in Kathmandu just a couple of hours
walk would have to count as a rest.
So there we were, two days trekking distance from Everest Base Camp, on
standby for an incident.
"We're trying to get a helicopter into Base Camp, but if that fails we'll
need him taking to Pheriche" "We'll know in a couple of hours if it's available"
Ah well, at least it was sunny and we could have a kip while we waited, and I
guess the views were better than we normally get around the Peak District. The
Nuptse-Lhotse ridge and our target of Island Peak ahead of us up the valley, Ama
Dablam to the South and Tawoche to the West.
Ronnie was being walked down the icefall with the help of the climbers from
all the different expeditions in the area, and a group of Sherpas had set off up
the icefall with the stretcher. They had him on oxygen and slowly brought him
down to Base Camp.
"No luck with the helicopter, so once the doctors have finished with him
we'll get him started on the descent" "If you can come up to meet him and take
him the rest of the way to Pheriche"
If we were going to get a helicopter into Pheriche it made sense to also
evacuate George Smith as well. George, 72, had made the trip up to Base Camp OK,
but his health had deteriorated during his stay there. Eventually he'd started
the descent, but at the speed he was capable of it would take a few days to
Pheriche.
We eventually decided to make a move. Ronnie had still not left Base Camp,
but we could get Mick over to Pheriche to borrow a stretcher for George, and
start moving it up the hill to Lobuje, about 3 hours walk away. Mick and Martin
went up to deliver the stretcher to the waiting Sherpas, and then continued on
to meet Ronnie near Gorak Shep, while the rest of us followed on behind to
assist the Sherpas on their descent with George.
The acclimatisation of the last 10 days had worked wonders. With that and the
switch from our normal 25 pound sacs to just a spare jacket and head torch meant
the journey which had taken a full day the first time was now over in less than
2 hours. The Sherpas had started the descent, but the stretcher was a standard
folding hospital stretcher, with a man on each corner it was far too wide for
most of the narrow paths. A set of rucksack shoulder straps and one of the
Sherpas head straps sufficed to fasten George on with reasonable safety, then
the Sherpas lifted the stretcher on to their shoulders and they were off.
We were off as well, jogging alongside at an astonishing speed trying to
assist with balance on the steep slopes and loose scree. The carry continued at
the same speed, no matter how steep or rough the path became, with a regular
rotation of manpower on the stretcher between the Sherpas and ourselves. Not a
carry method I would recommend for the UK, but in the circumstances amazingly
effective.
Darkness began to fall as we reached the half way point of Tuglha after about an
hour, but a round of lemon tea soon refreshed us for the next hour down to the
tea house in Pheriche.
Ronnie was well on the way down by now, although he was still about 2 hours
behind us. "We'll come up and meet you on the final valley section - give us a
call on the radio" "I will if I can keep up, the doctor is already about 10
minutes behind his patient!" Ronnie was obviously feeling much better, and no
doubt the oxygen was helping as well.
We sat in the tea house waiting for the call, devouring some much needed food
when Lhakpah, our Sirdar, came in with a kettle of chang - "You want to try?".
We'd been warned not try the local fermented rice brew until we were on our way
home, but we deserved a drink, and we had told Lhakpah that the drinks for the
Sherpas were on us. It certainly helped to numb the sore shoulders.
Some while later, when we received the call from the group with Ronnie, we
weaved our way up the valley to be met by him smiling and cracking jokes while
the rest of his party struggled to keep up. We were all ushered back into the
main room of the tea lodge, disturbing some of the Sherpas who had already
bedded down for the night, for some more food and chang until we all crashed out
for the night in the dormitory. We had been carrying our normal day gear so it
didn't matter that our tents, porters, kitchen, yaks and climbing gear were half
way to Island Peak.
The weather was bright and sunny the next day so by mid morning we heard the
distant noise of a helicopter reverberating up the valley and the two patients
and doctor were on their way down to Kathmandu.
Mission completed, OMRT chalks up another incident!
Perhaps the team member who had produced the joke T shirt before we left - "OMRT
on tour" with a list of our 1994 team trips to Scotland, Northern Ireland, Lundy
and the Himalayas knew more than he was saying!
So much for our easy day, and we'd lost more time from our schedule. As long
as we kept the radio turned off for the next few days we should be OK.
P.S. Ronnie seemed fully recovered by the time he left Kathmandu, and when we
met up with George in the Garden Hotel 3 weeks later he was back to full
strength.
Denzil Broadhurst is an electronics design engineer
****
The Researcher's Perspective
by David Collier
Conceived four years ago by a group of ex-Barts Alpine Club doctors the BMEME
started as a small group of doctors who wanted to climb Everest. With the
passage of time it grew into a highly complex Expedition. The unilateral
increase in fee charged by the Nepali Government (to $10,000 US) for each
climber to attempt the climb, made it necessary to broaden the membership of the
expedition. For those of us interested in the research opportunities of hypoxia
(low oxygen) this was to alter the entire project.
In addition to the seven climbers and twelve researchers there were a further
60 members recruited to the team. "Support team" members joined us for all of
the pre-expedition weekends and mountain medicine teaching courses (half of them
doctors). They paid the expedition a sum similar to the cost of a similar high
altitude "trekking" holiday. In return they were members of a prestigious
expedition, and volunteered for the medical research projects. It was the
success of this symbiotic relationship between researchers, climbers and support
members which made the most difference.
Before we left for Nepal, publicity efforts to help us included the climbing
team scaling the atrium window of the Lloyds building; Labour leader John Smith
came and saw displays of our research projects; we made a half -page cover
picture in the Independent and the Times. This was only one week before John
Smith died in our own hospital (where I was a Cardiology SHO at the time). We
felt the loss of this sincere and forthright man who had tried to help us very
keenly. A man of substance and conviction rather than the charisma and gloss we
so often see from people in political life.
The separate support groups took part in our pre-expedition research weekends
in London (Barts) and Stirling. The next time we all met up was at base camp,
5300m (18000 ft) on the Kumbu glacier. Groups of 8-12 members were tested on
arrival at base camp and then on their return after attempts (usually
successful) on mountains such as Island Peak, Pokalde or Lobuje East. Base Camp
was established in September by the climbing and research groups. It was the
focus of activity and linked the climbing team on the mountain with the
research, and all the support groups as they came and went.
The research group included contributors from 13 UK universities including
London (Barts, QMW, Kings, St Thomas', Charing Cross, Westminster, Oxford,
Leicester, The Institute of Ophthalmology, Moorfields Eye Hospital, Birmingham,
Edinburgh Glasgow and Northwick Park. We were unable to obtain umbrella funding
for all the projects and only raised one £13,000 grant from the British Heart
Foundation for a project on heart rate variability during hypoxia. Despite this
we were able to complete almost everything we set out to achieve, largely due to
the loan of equipment from all over Britain, mostly from the manufacturers
themselves. Work included studies on the eye led by Diana Depla FCOpth (a
project on visual field changes and hypoxia may shed light on the cause of
chronic simple glaucoma). Balance and hearing work from Martin Rosenburg at
Queen Mary and Westfield College addressed a theory about hair cell function and
low oxygen exposure. Peter Barry from Leicester carried out the first cough
challenge studies at altitude as well as recording nocturnal cough to confirm
the impression that cough really does increase as you go higher. Out study on
pulmonary oedema and endothelin-1 concentrations has just been beaten by a paper
out last week in 'Circulation' from a European group. Gerald Dubovitz from
Oxford performed studies on intestinal absorption and on the effect of sleeping
tablets at altitude. The effect of benzodiazepine sleeping tablets appears to be
dependent on how well acclimatised you are.
My own work, with collaborators from Kings College, Charing Cross and
Westminster and St. Thomas', was to investigate peripheral chemoreceptor
responses to carbon dioxide during acclimatisation. We have been able to show
for the first time that fast CO2 responses improve with acclimatisation to
altitude. This work was made more difficult by BOC, who supplied eight incorrect
gas cylinders! Normally this would have been annoying, but this order arrived
during a snowstorm at base camp - four cylinders to a yak and half of it was
wrong. You can't just fax or 'phone your problem. At 18,000 feet \par you are
stuck! The other major problem with our research was an avalanche. Just three
days after we had equipped our three main research tents (each the size of a
small living room) and our experimental work was underway, a large slab
avalanche from the west ridge of Everest at around 8,000 metres brought down a
huge volume of snow and wind blast. Researchers during World War II looked into
using powders and other materials to increase the destructive force of blast
from bombs, by increasing the mass of the moving air, in our case the spindrift
from the avalanche increased the effect of the blast. Our research tents were
all flattened, one 90lb tent, a McInnes box that was thrown over 40 feet through
the air, over a climber and his tent, smashed our main VHF radio mast (2 inch
tubing) and landed just in front of our mess tent.\par \par We were glad to be
alive, but spent much of the night rescuing precious and sensitive equipment
from the snow before rebuilding the camp the next day.
Although the conditions for climbing at extreme altitude were poor due to
excessive wind from the jetstream, which arrived early, two of our
doctor-climbers were able to reach the summit using oxygen. Dr. Charles Hornsby
and Dr. Roddie Kirkwood are both Scots, although Roddie chooses to live (and
climb) in New Zealand.
Alison Hargreaves, the best British woman climber (she climbed all the major
Alpine North faces in 1993 direct) was a semi-detached member of the team. She
was climbing as solo as possible and carried her own equipment. More than this,
she wanted to be the first woman to reach the summit without using supplementary
oxygen. Although Alison spent four nights at the South Col and seemed
surprisingly well there without oxygen, her summit bid was foiled by severe
winds and the sensations of impending frostbite.
Others were not so lucky. I treated one Scots climber who got to within 100
metres of being the first Briton to climb the second highest mountain, Lhotse.
His frostbite of the toes, however, was nothing to the severe hand and foot
injuries received by a sherpa working for a Nepali speed-climber. He had slept
with wet gloves at nearly 8,000m and subsequently lost most of his fingers in
Kathmandu.
One of our older support team members had to be stretchered in and out of
base camp over the Khumbu glacier. Fortunately one of our support groups was
dominated by most f the Oldham Mountain Rescue Team. A climber had a transient
ischaemic attack at Camp 1 and had to be evacuated down the icefall and out to
Pheriche where he left by helicopter. Thankfully he recovered fully.
What are the lasting memories? Sunrise over Everest, researching from 10
until 6 each day, the relief of seeing climbers return intact.
The expedition was successful beyond my hopes, and the unique structure
worked well - the vast variety of members all had something to contribute, from
a silicon chip designer for GEC Plessey, and oil refinery manager, a hatful of
GPs, gynaecologists, anaesthetists, pharmacists and paediatricians.
David Collier
****
The Ascent of Island Peak - 20,305 feet
by Mark Howarth
One of our ambitions in Group 5 was to climb Island Peak. The last time I had
wielded an ice-axe it had a wooden handle, which dates me a bit and I had never
worn crampons outside a climbing shop. Everest Base Camp was a good place for my
first lesson on ice climbing. Jim kindly told me I was doing everything wrong.
Now if anyone asks if I have done much on snow and ice, I casually mention that
I have climbed the Khumbu Icefall ... well, it's partly true.
A few days later we were at Island Peak Base Camp. This must rank as one of
the worlds most desolate spots. The next morning we walked up the mountain in
search or a bivvi site and wrestled with the decision - to climb or not to
climb. We found an ideal spot after about an hour and a half - a ledge of flat
ground among the rocks. The immortal words of Bill O'Connor echoed in our ears -
"... one of the great joys of Himalayan mountaineering is the high altitude
bivouac". Well, we would see about that. Back down for lunch and more
uncertainty over who wanted to go. Jeremy, George, Geraldine, Dawa and myself
were committed from the start and in the end only the five of us went.
We got a good send off from our friends that afternoon as we prepared to go
to our bedroom on the mountain while they waited below. We felt like real
mountaineers now. Then Chandra, our cook handed out four plastic bags containing
our packed suppers. Suddenly it was as if we were children out on a school trip.
Perhaps that's what mountaineers are.
Retracing our steps with enthusiasm, we were soon back at the bivvi site. In
the fast fading light we laid out mats and climbed into our sleeping bags. A
tiny crescent moon set soon after the sun. Soon there was a hard frost. We had
planned to leave at three in the morning and Dawa arrived to wake us soon after
two (he preferred the comfort of his own tent at base camp). I was glad he had
brought some water as mine had frozen overnight. Too cold to think, we packed
our rucksacks, put on boots and head torches and started stumbling uphill.
Plastic boots proved cumbersome but not as bad as I had feared. Walking up steep
rock and scree in the dark was very tiring. Knowing that I only had one spare
battery, I carried on using the first for far too long and soon my head torch
was providing only a feeble glow. Several times I decided I had had enough, and
was only put off turning back by the greater difficulty of going down in the
dark. I would wait till first light. But just as the sky began to lighten, we
reached the glacier and without saying a word we all put on crampons and
harnesses and roped together. There was no turning back now.
There is a magic about walking on the snow. We were now on the high Himalaya,
not among them. Soon it was broad daylight and there was a clear deep blue sky.
The agony and the breathlessness were not gone but were mixed with exhilaration
as we traversed the glacier with increasing confidence. On the steepest section
Dawa went ahead and put in a fixed rope which we climbed up. Then, roped
together, we walked along the summit ridge - all of two feet broad, with a dizzy
drop on either side. A short, if painful final climb took us to the top. I would
have yelled with joy if my lungs had let me.
Time for photos, hugs all round and a swig from the hip flask. This was well
earned ecstasy. As we moved around on the summit we never thought to unclip from
the rope. By the time we made off we were tied in a long knot like a cat's
cradle and had to clamber over and under each other to get free. I can't imagine
what Dawa thought of us. But I do know that I wouldn't have been there without
him.
We had to be off the snow before it got too soft so we soon headed back down
the ridge, abseiled down the rope into the cwm where we stopped for a short rest
and some food. There were better opportunities to admire the amazing scenery on
the more relaxed descent. Then on down and down and down. I think I have never
been so tired as when I arrived back at base camp. Aware that Ann was videoing
me as I approached camp I tried to put some spring in my step but failed
miserably.
Mark Howarth is a General Practitioner in West Sussex.
*****
Parchamo and group 1
by Denzil Broadhurst
"What do you mean, Parchamo isn't on our list of peaks?" There we were on the
way to Kathmandu airport, hoping to fly out to Lukla, and Rai had just informed
us that Parchamo wasn't included in our climbing permits. We'd done our group
planning back in May at a weekend in Saddleworth, and the final crowning moment
of our expedition was going to be the ascent of Parchamo. We were stunned!
As soon as we got to the airport we pinned down Rai and Sonam, one of the
Thamserku directors, and over a Fanta, Chris and I discussed the situation with
them. After going round the houses a few times without success, and with them
claiming that Simon had agreed to no ascents of Parchamo, a sudden light seemed
to come in Rai's eyes when he realised that we were not intending to descend via
the Rolwaling valley. The whole problem had been a misunderstanding, and Rai's
attitude changed completely. There wasn't much time to sort the permits, he
didn't know if the expedition would cover the costs, and wasn't sure of what the
costs were going to be, but he was prepared to try and sort it out.
We didn't fly that day anyway, so a meeting took place later that afternoon
at Thamserku, with Chris and Pete Smith negotiating the deal. Finally, success,
they would sort the permits and make sure they met up with us while we were
trekking, and if the original agreement with Thamserku didn't cover the cost of
the permit our group would split the costs between us.
Our problem now was that we were losing time in the flight to Lukla, and our
schedule was aggressive. We made various fall-back plans, including missing
Pokalde and Gokyo if necessary, but Parchamo was right at the end and plenty
could happen before that.
Almost 5 weeks later, having assisted in the evacuation of Ronnie and George,
and cutting our second visit to Base Camp to the minimum, our final version of
the schedule was unrolling. We'd sprinted from Island Peak to Base Camp and back
to Namche, the yaks and climbing gear having been left in Dingboche for most of
the time since they couldn't cover the distances fast enough. Only Mick, Martin
and Jamie had attempted the slag heap of Pokalde, and we had missed out the trip
to Gokyo completely.
We headed up the valley towards Thame, racing past a number of yaks. How
things had changed from the start of the expedition when the sound of yaks
behind you was a warning to move out the way, and a good excuse for a brief
rest.
We were sitting in a small tea house in Thame and wondering if we could top
out on Parchamo at the same time as the Everest team reached their summit, when
we heard over the radio that 2 of them were already there. Great news! Now we
had to succeed as well.
Jamie spent most of the night throwing up and the Sirdar's father was also
ill, so we left them at the camp site in Thame and headed up the valley. We had
a good chat with one of the monks in the monastery, he originally came from the
village, but had spent some time in the USA. We heard from Jamie that the monk
came down later to see if he or Kami needed anything.
Lunch at Tengbo, once we had found where the Sherpas were waiting for us,
then less than an hour to our base camp. The following day was the climb up the
Taschi Lapcha to the bivvi site, but before we left, our yak driver who had been
a monk, offered to do a Puja for us. It was one of their holy days, and they put
up the prayer flags across the nearby crag and set up the altar. The smoke
drifted across us as we sat and took part in the food and drink offerings.
The ascent to the pass was one of the hardest days we had done. A few hours
working our way up the steep moraine with large areas still very loose and
indistinct. We assumed there must have been a significant rockfall in the last
year or so. The glacier crossing was similarly difficult going and also often
unmarked. We watched a German party descending from the pass, with their porters
struggling on the ice and snow in their tennis shoes.
The final climb was a scree slope, which felt as long as the Great Stone
Shoot in the Cuillin, only now we were nearly at 18,000 feet and I was carrying
a sac weighing almost 50 pounds. Mick, Stu and Martin were already in their
bivvi below an overhang and Andy joined them, but Chris and I looked at the
recent scars on the rocks all around and opted for a spot in the snow out of
range of any likely rock fall.
The Sirdar of one of the groups camped nearby asked where our Guide was.
"What, no Guide!" Then where were our Sherpas, porters, our tents? "None!", "You
British.....HARD!"
Stu's old knee injury was troubling him after the hard going, so he snuggled
up in his bivvi bag as the rest of us left around 3.30. Mick stormed the hill
with Martin pulling out all the stops and staying with him, while Chris, Andy
and I made our more sedate way up. The whole route was a steep angled snow slope
which we climbed alpine style. Sure enough, by the time we were about half way
up Mick and Martin came storming back down. Martin had kept up, but without the
energy to bother putting a new film in his camera he had taken no photos.
The weather had been threatening all morning with dark clouds at about 24,000
ft and the occasional strong gust pinning us to the spot as we were peppered by
the spindrift. The Sherpa guide with a group of Venezuelans reckoned there would
be snow by lunchtime.
10.00 am and we were stood on the top, or rather within a few 10's of metres
since the final section of the ridge was a series of dramatic crevasses. For the
first time I had needed to wear my duvet jacket all morning, and my compact
camera had to be kept tucked inside to stop it freezing. Both Andy's and Chris's
cameras packed up on the summit but my trusty old OM1 carried on regardless.
An hour was spent with photos and radio calls to base camp and to Gerald and
Nick on the top of Lobuje East, with a celebratory bar of chocolate, then a
descent in just 1 hour to the bivvi site. We packed up the gear then began the
long descent to the base camp for 4.30 p.m.. It had been a long hard day, but
one of the best.
Overnight the wind picked up, blowing down the mess tent, and threatening the
rest of the tents. We woke up to an al fresco breakfast in the snow. Perhaps the
Puja had helped keep the bad weather away for those vital 24 hours, there was no
way we would have been climbing today. Time to go home, we were due to be in
Lukla the following day, but it had certainly been the climax of a great trip.
****
Only 23 kilograms!
by Denzil Broadhurst
So we were going to have to manage with 23 kg in the hold baggage and the hand
baggage limit of 5 kg. We might end up wearing a lot for the flight out!
I'd cleared a space in the loft and all the gear was strewn across the floor
with most of it sorted into piles: must have, probably need, might need, and
luxuries. Before I'd got all the gear together I'd done a quick weighing and it
was already over 30 kg. The luxuries pile seemed to be growing.
I guess the weight limit wasn't too bad for those who were only trekking, but
we were planning on doing some of the peaks. Crampons, ice axes, helmet, rope
and harness, a selection of normal climbing gear such as crabs and slings. What
about the other climbing hardware? Chris and I had planned to take a set of
chocks between us for belays, but we knew that they probably wouldn't be used.
Chris would take a selection of smaller ones on wires, and I would take some
larger hexes. A pair of jumars and a tuber went on the pile.
The plastic boots went in, and the lightweight fabric boots should be fine
for all the trekking. A pair of sandals? They'll make a pleasant change in the
evening. Trainers for the journey out - no, the boots would be okay.
Clothes? 3 pairs of underpants, it's only 7 weeks! 1 T shirt to travel in and
1 long sleeved shirt if I need to keep the sun off, I was planning to buy
another T shirt in Kathmandu anyway. 2 pairs of thick socks and 2 pairs of thin
ones would have to do. One pair of Troll trousers, a pair of shorts for hot days
plus the tracksuit bottoms for climbing.
Thermal gear? Just how cold was it going to be? A couple of thermal vests
plus a pair of long johns went into the pile. 2 pairs of gloves, a fleece
balaclava and a skiing fleece headband went in as well. It's too easy to lose a
pair of gloves and they could be crucial while climbing.
A huge pile of Buffalo gear! I was relying on it, and since they recommend
not wearing anything underneath that saves some clothes. Would my 3/4 season
sleeping bag be enough? I'd bought a good lightweight sleeping bag to go inside
it for the really cold nights but it was over 1 kg.
The Goretex had to go in. Jacket, overtrousers and mitts made sure I had a
full waterproof shell. Most wet conditions in the UK are dealt with by the
Buffalo gear, but the Goretex is always there in the sack.
What about the camera. A second hand short zoom for the OM1 rather than a
selection of lenses. It's incredibly rugged and doesn't rely on a battery. I'll
put in the little weatherproof compact as well, far easier while climbing.
Everything in the barrel. No! It won't all fit, and it's already up to 28 kg.
Put the light, bulky stuff in the rucksack and take it separately. It's all in
but it's getting close to 4 |